Pool Heat Exchanger Keeps Leaking: Which Tube Material Lasts Longer?
When a pool heat exchanger starts leaking, should you replace it with the same model or choose more corrosion-resistant tubing? That decision can affect how soon another repair is needed.
If corrosion from pool water has been confirmed as the cause of tube failure, titanium tubing is worth considering, particularly for saltwater pools or pools fitted with a salt chlorinator. Before choosing a replacement material, however, identify where the leak is coming from. Leaking connections, failed seals and damaged tube walls require different remedies.
Identify the Leak Location First
Recording the leak location and the damaged component is more useful than simply asking which metal is best. During inspection, ask the maintenance team to check the following:
Leaks around connections or end covers: Check the connections and seals, and establish whether the heat exchanger tubes themselves are affected.
Holes or noticeable thinning in the tube walls: Photograph the damaged areas and review them alongside the original material specification, water quality records and operating history.
Leaks after a winter shutdown or an abnormal pressure event: Include frost damage and excessive pressure in the investigation.
Bowman's pool heat exchanger manual states that exceeding the maximum working pressure can cause damage or leakage. It also calls for protection against frost damage during winter shutdowns. Where these issues are involved, address the operating or shutdown conditions before deciding whether a material change is necessary. Bowman Installation, Operation & Maintenance Guide
Recheck Material Suitability for Saltwater Pools
Equipment that worked well before may not be suitable for a later change in water treatment. If a pool has been converted to a saltwater system or fitted with a salt chlorinator, check the heat exchanger's suitability again.
When describing the application to the equipment manufacturer, include the pool type, whether a salt chlorinator is used, and available water quality records. Describing the application only as "pool use" can leave out information that matters to material selection.
Bowman's manual specifically excludes its stainless steel pool heat exchangers from saltwater pools and pools fitted with salt chlorinators, and identifies copper-nickel or titanium options for these applications. These are the manufacturer's requirements for its equipment, rather than a universal rule for every stainless steel heat exchanger. Bowman Material Suitability Guidance
Titanium also has documented applications in pool heating equipment. Pahlén's Hi-Temp Titanium heat exchanger, for example, uses a titanium coil and is intended for installations with a high corrosion risk, including saltwater pools and pools using salt chlorinators. Where the original tube material has been found unsuitable for the water conditions, this provides a practical reference for discussing alternatives with the equipment manufacturer. Pahlén Product Information
Address Installation and Operating Issues Alongside Material Selection
When reassessing the tube material, check whether the conditions that damaged the original equipment are still present.
Direct exposure to concentrated treatment chemicals and flow rates outside the equipment's requirements should also be investigated. Bowman's sizing guidance warns that direct chemical dosing can damage the heat exchanger and stresses the importance of matching flow rates to the equipment. Bowman Pool Heat Exchanger Sizing Guide
Give the equipment manufacturer details of the dosing point's position relative to the heat exchanger, routine water quality records, and operating temperatures, pressures and flow rates. Any adjustments should follow the installation and maintenance requirements for the specific model.
Even when titanium tubing is selected, the equipment designer or manufacturer still needs to confirm the tube diameter, wall thickness, heat transfer area and connection method. Material suitability is one part of the replacement plan.
Request a Clear Replacement Plan
Provide the equipment manufacturer with the model, original tube material, leak photographs, water treatment method and operating records in one document for assessment.
The replacement plan should specify which components will be changed, the materials to be used and the permitted operating conditions. Before ordering, clarify whether the existing equipment allows tube bundle replacement, whether related fittings also need changing, and whether the replacement will meet the required heating duty.
For equipment manufacturing or tube processing projects where titanium tubing has already been specified, Baoji Tengyuan New Metal Materials Co., Ltd. supplies titanium tube with dimensions made to customer requirements. Send the designer-approved grade, outside diameter, wall thickness, length and quantity through our enquiry page to discuss your material supply requirements.




